Alan,

Very interesting if true. I think it may still be a bit premature to update the site to say AC modems are OK until it can be tested, but if someone ends up getting a new ‘r2’ version and it does work, please let us know and we’ll get it added to the list.

Nigel

On Aug 16, 2021, at 12:57 PM, Alan Dieringer [WX7L] <WX7L@westseattlearc.org> wrote:

Dear PSDR List Members,

HamWAN's PDF comparing various devices shows the QRT 5 ac:   

However, on the webpage http://hamwan.org/Standards/Component%20Engineering/Client%20Hardware.html it states: "Avoid Mikrotik's 802.11ac modems. These are incapable of tuning the 5 and 10 MHz channels used by HamWAN and are therefore incompatible."

It is not unusual to find outdated material relating to electronic devices, and I think this is the case here, so I thought it best to check with the manufacturer.  Below is the response from MikroTik Support confirming that the new version of the QRT 5 ac also supports 5 and 10 MHz band widths because of a new chipset in the "r2" revision.  Just need to make sure you don't get the old version.

73
Alan WX7L

From: Rūdolfs P. (Jira) <support@mikrotik.com>                         Date: Mon, Aug 16, 2021 at 4:33 AM
Subject: MikroTik support #[SUP-57126]: Question about QRT 5 ac
To: <WX7L@westseattlearc.org>
—-—-—-—
Please REPLY ABOVE THIS LINE ^ (for faster response, use our support portal).

Hello,

Apologies for the delayed response. QRT 5ac is quite a unique situation. After additional investigation regarding the support of 5/10Mhz channel-width, I can say that, if you buy the router today, it should support these channel-widths. It has two public revisions, where the newer one (/r2) has a different wireless chipset (QCA-9892) that supports these channel-widths when compared to the old one (QCA-9882). To make sure you are getting the right one, you can ask the distributor to ensure that you will have the r2 revision, which can be found on the box/case label at the end of serial number, for example - A13B0DXXXXXX/0XX/r2.
I will make sure to update the Web description of the QRT 5ac, as it currently shows that it has QCA-9882 wireless chip and the older one is long discontinued.

Best regards,

 
Rūdolfs P.

_______________________________________________
PSDR mailing list
PSDR@hamwan.org
http://mail.hamwan.net/mailman/listinfo/psdr